Menu of Madison Street steakhouse and grill in Lancaster, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

Madison Street Steakhouse and Grill in Lancaster, WI, stands out as a beacon for steak lovers and barbecue enthusiasts alike. Nestled on 103 N Madison St, this restaurant masterfully balances rustic charm with refined flavors, creating an inviting atmosphere where quality and care define every dish.

The menu’s highlight is undeniable—the BBQ Brisket Sandwich is a smoky, tender masterpiece that melts in your mouth, complemented perfectly by their famous Cheese Curds. These golden, crispy bites deliver the quintessential Wisconsin experience, with just the right amount of crisp and melt. The steaks here, particularly the New York Strip and Sirloin paired with a baked potato, showcase the house’s dedication to sourcing and preparation. Patrons like Wyatt Michel sing praises of the tender, farm-to-table beef, reinforcing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and traceability.

The sides, such as the garlic mashed potatoes mentioned by Kevin Mccallister and Micki Uppena, are robust and flavorful, adding depth without overshadowing the mains. For those seeking lighter fare, the House Salad offers fresh, crisp balance to the hearty plates.

Pairing is seamless with their thoughtfully curated cocktail and liquor selection. From Aviation Gin to Crown Royal and decadently crafted Old Fashioneds, the bar elevates the dining experience. Amy K’s delight in her Cosmopolitan and Cassie Fitzgerald’s endorsement of the cocktails affirm the skill behind the bar. The House Wine—Cabernet Sauvignon—complements the robust steaks, while non-alcoholic options like Bottled Root Beer and Sparkling Grape provide refreshing balance.

Desserts deserve mention as well, particularly the Tuxedo Cheesecake. It’s rich, creamy, and an indulgent finish that many diners have found irresistible. Cassie Fitzgerald’s experience of squeezing in cheesecake after a full meal captures this sweet conclusion perfectly.

Service at Madison Street Steakhouse and Grill aligns with its curated menu—friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable, enhancing the overall experience without overshadowing the spotlight on food. This is a restaurant where every element—from the farm-to-table beef to the well-crafted cocktails and warm service—works harmoniously.

In sum, Madison Street Steakhouse and Grill offers a heartfelt, authentic steakhouse experience. It’s a destination for those who appreciate perfectly cooked steaks, bold flavors, and a thoughtfully constructed menu that pays homage to local heritage and culinary craftsmanship.